Dear Standard Bank, Internet banking division

brad's picture

Hi,

The improvements to internet banking have some bugs, it seems.

I have had the experience twice now during "once off payments" that I get an error of "Internet banking is currently unavailable" when I go through with a transaction. It seems to be related to sending payment confirmations. It is bad behaviour because the transaction goes through, but the user (me) does not get a valid indication the payment has succeeded until a notification (sms, or email) comes through, or manually checks if there is a mention on the account transacted from/to.

I would also like to say that some of the "improvements" are actually a degradation, in terms of usability. The screen is more cluttered with graphics and text, and on my screen (which is running at 1280x800) has information pushed "below the fold". I would suggest that whoever is in charge of usability and new features looks into buying a copy of "Defensive Web Design" (http://www.amazon.com/Defensive-Design-Web-improve-messages/dp/073571410...), and other texts discussing usability on the web. While not absolutely correct, the EyeTRAC studies are a good reference point.

I (as a web developer) find it depressing that a service I am paying for has degraded usability, when the changes were supposedly improvements. It is not a wholely poor experience (there are some improvements, but my general experience is that the interface has become more confusing, not less confusing)

I am posting this email on my blog, and you are welcome to respond publicly (in the form of a comment), or as an email response.

--
Brad Whittington

Trackback URL for this post:

http://whijo.net/trackback/434

Hi Brad

I would be very very surprised if you get any response from Standard Bank and even more surprised if that response is one that makes you feel like anyone there gives a shit or has a clue.

Standard Bank used to be a very good bank but in the last year or so their customer service has dropped radically and their website and online banking has suffered from what appears to be a lack of concern for the customers experience.

Have a look at Capitec bank... I'm moving shortly.

j.

Nice post thanks!

A free sex video of sweet natural hairy Swamy Nithyananda’ having sex with a top tamil actress and other nude girls was broadcast on TV live and has shocked people across India. Naked girls were typed on video by anonumous author. Since a Swamy is supposed to be a spiritual person- this revelation has followers questioning hairy bush Nithyananda's faith. Originally this xxx video was posted on youtube but then moved to other sex tube portals.
ABB728019384 порно видео

Did you know? The Sport Supplement that are most important to the improvement of a person’s fitness are proteins, Creatine, glutamine, and multi vitamins. Proteins are usually available in the form of powder which easily converts to amino acids. They are responsible for growth, as related to muscles and they repair these muscles from damage.Using Sport Supplement, Should teens take sport supplement

Comparability and replica Longines watches distinction essay is Replica A.Lange Sohne without fake handbags doubt one of fake Jaeger Le Coultre Watches the replica Breitling watches commonest assignments in American replica Rado watches excessive colleges and Replica TAG Heuer Watches universities. designer handbags In the sort fake Balenciaga handbags of replica watches an essay the Replica Versace scholars have to compare two (in some essays replica Jaeger LeCoultre watches a number of) issues, problems, occasions or ideas- replica watches replica tag heuer and consider their resemblances and differences. This type of an essay advances and develops your crucial replica Piaget watches considering in addition to an essay your argumentation and understanding of the importance of the Replica IWC Watches occasions fake Marni handbags and issues that you simply compare.
There s an instance of Replica Loewe the headings of among the compare/contrast assignments.
Compare and fake TAG Heuer Watches contrast the weather situations for the growing of the cotton between Texas and California.
Examine fake watches the strategy to the Soviet Union of F.D. Roosevelt and H. Truman. Replica Tissot What are the cheap clothing similarities/the variations of their Replica Cartier coverage?
Compare and the essays contrast the flicks God Replica Thomas Wylde handbags Farther replica louis vuitton and Once fake A. Lange and Sohne Watches upon a time inAmerica. />
Generally, fake chanel chances replica watches are you ll be asked to check, replica Jaeger Le Coultre sometimes you may be replica IWC watches requested to contrast, and on a number of events Replica Omega each actions mentioned ought to be performed.
But, on the similar fake Jaeger Le Coultre Watches time comparison/contrast might replica IWC watches be a part of nike shoes some essay as w

This is my second visit to your blog. We are starting a brand new initiative in the same niche as this blog. Your blog provided us with valuable information to work on. You have done a marvellous job.
oil painting
oil paintings
cheap paintings
discount paintings
paintings for sale
oil paintings for sale
cheap paintings for sale
large paintings
landscape paintings
landscape paintings for sale

Im really glad to be here on your site, pariuri sportive because i`ve discovered usefull information for me. poker online I`l be back bwin with pleasure to read something new. Good luck bet365 and have a nice day .

Resources like the one you mentioned here is very useful! I will post a link to this page on my blog. I am sure my visitors will find that very useful.
Real Estate Dubai | furnished apartments Dubai | Dubai rental

As a professional IT study materials provider, Pass4sure is specially designed for IT candidates who want to pass any IT exams, supported by a powerful team for product research and development, as well as website development and operation. Its vendors like Cisco, Microsoft, IBM, Sun, compTIA, HP, etc, are all positioned as leaders in the IT field.The Most Popular Vendors List : HP exam Oracle exam Oracle certification Cisco certification The Most Popular Certifications List : NCSE exam NCTS certification CCDP exam CCDP exam SCJP certification JNCIA certification IBM DB2 certification CCIP exam SCJP certification CCDP certification CCVP exam CCIE exam The Most Popular exams List : 350-050 642-436 HP0-S21 646-363 156-315.65 VCP-310 350-001 CISSP SK0-002 JK0-016 1Z0-051 CISSP JN0-331 646-363 642-524 650-180 220-702 642-892 642-681 220-602 640-816 Click Pass4sure to get more information!

Hi there, I dont know if I am writing in a proper board but I have got a problem with activation, link i receive in email is not working... http://whijo.net/?bbee2cc34397a31c40f8fe584c8,

Hybrid road bikes are becoming more and more popular fake chanel with both people who are trying to stay in shape, and those who simply enjoy replica watches riding for fun. Although you will find that there is a substantial price tag with most of these bikes, there are places where you can get them cheaper, and in the long run replica watches it Replica Cartier Watches s fake Giverchy handbags worth it. You Replica Ebel Watches will fake TW Steel Watches have replica louis vuitton a bike that will not replica louis vuitton start falling apart right away designer watches and one that you fake Marc Jacobs handbags will enjoy riding every time you go out. One of the reasons that these bikes are becoming more popular is because of how comfortable they are as well shoe sales as Replica Tissot how smooth of a ride you get from them. Unlike many other types of bikes, you replica Zenith will find that Replica Christian Dior Watches you won replica hermes t feel every little bump replica IWC in the road. Replica Panerai They replica louis vuitton have replica watches news amazing shock absorbers that will give you a fake Casio Watches smoother replica Tag Heuer ride clothing store than you have Replica Versace ever experienced replica watches before.

Welded Steel Pipe is the same as welded stainless steel pipe. Why Successful Career Women all Want carbon steel pipe ? God Knows!It's the steel pipe that made of plate or strip though curling and welding. Seize the Moment!! sanitary pipe are the Favorite of

Welded steel pipe manufacturing process is simple, the efficiency is high, specifications is variety and equipment capital is small. 6 Facts about boiler tube You Should RememberBut it's not as strong as seamless steel tube.Since the 1930s, specifications of welded pipe have been growing which is taking place of the seamless stainless steel pipe.API Pipe are the First in the List of Most Wanted Attachments in 2009

According to the form of welding, welded steel pipe can divided into longitudinal and spiral welded pipe. Trend Alert! Celebrities in carbon steel pipe

Longitudinal pipe's developing fast these days not only because its production process is simple, the efficiency is high, but also its low cost. What is Best for 70 Somethings? Exquisite Needle Valve !The longitudinal pipe is not as strong as the spiral one.

Generally, the pipe with a smaller caliber almost use straight seam welding.Large-diameter pipe use spiral welding.

Tell them what they did right too -- don't just tell them they did something right and then withold the information about what it was.

I quite like their new beneficiary grouping function -- and also that they finally allow beneficiaries to be sorted.

I haven't tried a once-off payment yet via the new interface, so I haven't had any issues so far.

I hope you get some sort of response from them, but chances are you'll have to send them a follow-up message written with a more curt tone. I know that the last time I had issues with them, I did.

On the plus side, at least they have cottoned on to some sort of usability...something that is still woefully overdue in many quarters. Perhaps the operations you tried were not something they tested in their set usability tasks, or maybe they didn't recruit geeks of a pedantic nature ;) I know for our usability we tried not to get any 'high' internet users, as they have requirements far and above what the average user expects.

Hey- at least you'll never be average.

Hi Brad

Standard Bank appreciates the feedback on the recent changes made to Internet banking. Positive feedback gives us the sense of satisfaction and achievement; and this inspires us to continue doing the right things. Negative feedback gives us an opportunity to review and address those issues that our customers are not happy with. As mentioned by jenbug above, the challenge that we have is that we have a single platform to satisfy the needs of a wide range of our customers. When we design our Internet banking application, the composition of the groups of people used during usability testing covered the range of our types of users (novice, savvy, personal, business, etc) and at the end of the day the design eventually implemented satisfied the majority of the user requirements raised. Everyone has different tastes and, as one can understand, it is quite a feat to satisfy everyone. We admit we are not at that stage yet, but we will keep trying.

Addressing the specific issues raised;

On the payment confirmations on once-off payments, the error “Internet banking is currently unavailable”
Response: We are aware of this error and we are in the final stages of testing a solution to this. We will be implementing this solution in the next couple of days.

“The screen is more cluttered with graphics and text, and on my screen (which is running at 1280x800) has information pushed below the fold’ ”.
Response: We are in the process of neatening up some of the screens, this will be available as soon as testing is successfully completed.

We welcome the feedback, keep it coming, we view improvements to usability as an ongoing exercise.

Regards
Itai
Online Banking
Standard Bank

brad's picture

Thanks for the feedback, and I look forward to the improvements. I only complain because I want the services I use to be the best, and I do understand the difficulty in rolling out such massive operations. That said, being more transparent about issues that do exist, and where there are solutions in the pipeline is a lot better than the useless banners saying "Internet banking is improving". You could give private news feeds to logged in users, making it public where you know you have shortcomings, and what you are doing to rectify them. Alternatively, services like http://getsatisfaction.com are designed for interacting with customers, for both good and bad feedback.

The point is, make sure you respond (somehow) to how people are feeling about your service. I have sent emails in the past and never got a response back, of any kind (and it seems like this is a common experience). A response could even be a notice on the front page when you log in, with current major issues you are dealing with.

You have a choice, pretending like your service is best, and making customers feel like they are whingers who will never get a response (because they are wrong anyway), or being honest about the shortcomings and the issues faced. I am a customer, I pay for the service, I have a right to having my voice heard (positive and negative), and when you only publish positive feedback on your site, then you turn me into the bad guy, the complainer.

Just my 10c worth.

Is your commentary worth 10c because of inflation? ;-)

brad's picture

I got a final response from SB, saying they had forwarded my suggestions (above) to the R&D dept. as they are looking at implementing customer suggestions. I am not going to reprint their email verbatim as I never asked/got permission.

I really hope they can get to grips with the "read write web", and crowd sourcing research.

brad's picture

SB emailed me again with a response calling into question my man-hood (jokes, their emails are marked as confidential, so I can't republish it, but I can republish my response, which might give clues as to their original email):

Hi,

All this new fangled technology is quite confusing. You are welcome to spare the condescending attitude (Oh look, another silly user, unhappy about change), and actually address usability of internet banking (because it is far from simple, and violates the principle of least surprise on a number of occasions).

It is true that change is the hardest thing to swallow, but, for example, when I upgraded my PC to the newest version of Ubuntu, I welcomed the changes because they were improvements, they decreased the amount of time it takes me to do my day job. Changing my mental flow, and adpating to the new processes was easy because the changes made sense, and so they got my buy in.

You can get used to a yak kicking you in the head every morning, it doesn't mean it is the best way to start a day.

I would like to help though, I do usability as a day job, and I would like to be involved in user trials in future developments, so I can become a resource, and not a prick who argues on the internet.

i totally agree with every word you written dude, cheers mate!!!

Watch Wholesale

thanks for taking the pain to provide us with such great information dude, cheers mate!!!

payday loan

Darb, you grow up so quickly. These rants are starting to sound like the "Big Rant to Microsoft, Dell and Toshiba in 2006". I'd say you keep at it, though you chances of any constructive responses are unlikely. Though the web dev team for SB is most probably going to read this blog entry and hate on you. I'd welcome their comments... Though chances are they're just puppets for the big corporate entity and probably sit in meetings saying "this is a bad idea" and then someone in a suit saying "I like the colours and the bold text, and why do we need to fund support for this foxfire thing?"

Just read your other SB post. It's really irritating when these things happen in succession. I was trying to purchase a url yesterday for some R3000, and some banks have added an extra confirmation in for credit card purchases which bombed out the transaction.

I am glad to see you made the effort to contact them with concerns. With any luck the suggestions will get passed on to someone, who will take credit for the idea (but that's OK - if some good comes out of it for the user). If not, at least you gave it the ole college try.

Find the best carnival cruise deals online. Start traveling carnival cruise deals today. Get the best cruise deals!

Just wanted to give you a shout from the valley of the sun, great information. Much appreciated.
Regards,
Online Brokers

carries thousands of handbags and purses from top designers and famous labels
handbags
cheap bags
Handbags - Huge Selection of Handbags Purses
handbags shop
Links London Jewellery on Sale
Links of London
Canvas Handbags
best Links of London jewelry provider. You can find the wholesale links of london jewellery here. There are Links of London Sweetie
Links London
Handbags,Diaper bags,Laptop bags,Camera bags,Golf bags
Business & Laptop
Backpacks Handbags

I also use internet banking for my online transaction purposes.

Thanks

watch full movies online for free without downloading

barclays is the best international bank in developing countries . . .

Cancellation Holidays

It is bad behaviour because the transaction goes through, but the user (me) does not get a valid indication the payment has succeeded until a notification (sms, or email) comes through, or manually checks if there is a mention on the account transacted from/to.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Captcha
This question is used to make sure you are a human visitor and to prevent spam submissions.
Syndicate content

Recent comments

About this website

Whijo.net is the online internets of Bradley Whittington, Amanda Joseph, and our son Finley James Whittington. "Whijo" is 29% Whittington, 33% Joseph, and 37% Internet. Quite Web 2.0 of us.